Why Deku Should Have Kept One for All

by

Summary

  • Deku’s sacrifice of One for All to save Shigaraki reflects his noble character development.
  • Deku’s worthiness of One for All emphasizes his resilience and heroic efforts throughout the series.
  • Keeping One for All challenges Deku and the power itself to move forward post All for One.

In the anime “My Hero Academia,” Deku’s journey with the power of One for All came to a climactic end when he decided to relinquish his power to connect with Shigaraki, aiming to ultimately vanquish All for One. This pivotal moment was undeniably spectacular for the series, but it raises questions about whether it was the most fitting decision for Deku’s character and the broader narrative.

In the eyes of some readers, this plot twist was surprising, as they had anticipated a victorious ending for Deku with the power of One for All still in his possession. However, others found it fitting with the story’s progression. The question remains: which perspective carries more weight and better serves the narrative? Delving into a few chapters that depict Deku after losing One for All, we witness how he copes with this loss and decides to pursue heroism on his own terms. Yet, let us ponder over an alternate scenario where Deku retained One for All – what would this universe look like?

Why Deku Should Have Lost One For All

Deku’s Heroism Was Never Tied to Having a Quirk

Firstly, let’s discuss the points favoring Deku’s loss of One for All. It’s crucial to understand these perspectives before delving into why he shouldn’t have lost it. In Horikoshi’s narrative, there were clear indications that Deku was headed towards losing One for All. The creator’s approach to Deku and his character development, which emphasized constant challenges, testing of spirit, and burdening him with the weight of the world, all point towards a potential loss of One for All. This narrative strategy served to create a heroic, self-sacrificing image for Deku that was consistently reinforced throughout the story.

Apart from being significant, the manner in which Deku surrendered One for All was remarkably fitting too. Though it was up to him how to utilize One for All, he opted to give it to Shigaraki, not just to destroy All for One, but also to save him. This selfless act might have been the most valuable thing in existence, yet Deku relinquished it to ensure others’ safety and to become a hero for someone who had never truly experienced one before. It’s challenging to argue that Deku’s loss of One for All was incorrect; instead, his decision was thoughtful and justified within the storyline. However, pondering the consequences if Deku retained One for All opens up even more captivating plot developments.

Why Deku Should Have Kept One for All

Deku Earned This Power

Throughout the series, Deku has been on a journey of self-discovery, learning to value his own worth beyond his quirk. It’s possible that some viewers might find it satisfying if Deku were to lose One for All. However, as the story progressed, an additional moral message was introduced, making the decision to let go of One for All a more complex one.

Right from the start, All Might ensures Deku that he received One for All because he deserved it, not because he was born with a quirk like others. Instead, he demonstrated through his actions that he was heroic enough to receive it. As the story progresses, we discover more about why One For All is ideally suited for Deku, or conversely, why Deku is perfect for One for All. This is significant in the narrative as it highlights that Deku not only demonstrated himself as a worthy hero but also proves himself deserving of this power due to his quirklessness.

Consequently, it’s meaningful that Deku retains One For All because it validates his dedication throughout the series. Deku has given up a lot for others, even if he found it a blessing to do so, it would have been immensely gratifying to see his sacrifices and determination recognized by keeping the power he had nurtured.

Challenging Deku and One for All on How to Move Forward

In a more conversational style: A key aspect of the story in “One for All” is not just about defeating All for One, but also about overcoming destiny. So, it’d be intriguing to see how Deku and One for All could shape a society post-All for One, and use their power to build a hopeful future. This could make for an engaging arc in a potential sequel series or even a separate story set after the original timeline.

Initially, we witness through All Might how his destiny shaped him. After losing One for All and taking on Deku as his trainee, he pondered over his reason to exist, having been the Symbol of Peace for such a long time. However, by the climax of the narrative, he discovered a fresh sense of purpose, understanding that he had much more to live for. If we were to construct a similar story arc for the bearers of One for All and Deku, it would be deeply rewarding. Deku, a character who once believed himself to be worthless due to his lack of a quirk, might struggle with the burden of possessing what could be the most potent one. How would he manage this immense responsibility?

Reframing the perspective, it’d be deeply satisfying to conclude the narrative if Deku retained One for All, given its evolving and expanding role within the storyline.

You can stream ‘My Hero Academia’ on Crunchyroll, Hulu, Netflix, and Amazon Prime Video (where available). Alternatively, you can read the manga version on VIZ Media’s Shonen Jump app or website.

Read More

2025-02-22 23:07