Why Didn’t The Crow Remake Succeed?

Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?

Key Takeaways

  • The 2024 Crow remake failed due to its dated ’90s attitude and aesthetics, not translating well to the 2020s.
  • The original 1994 film’s impact, success, and tragic legacy overshadow the need for a modern reboot.
  • The Crow’s tragic backstory, Brandon Lee’s legacy, and the unmatched cult status of the original define its lasting appeal.

As a film enthusiast and student of cinema history, I have had the privilege of witnessing some truly exceptional performances that leave a lasting impact. Among these, Brandon Lee’s portrayal of Eric Draven, also known as The Crow, stands out as one of the most poignant and memorable.


There’s a strong urge among film studios to revive classic ’90s horror movies that have left an indelible mark on audiences, and this is particularly true for those from the decade of neon and grunge. While it’s exciting to observe the ongoing development of the Scream series, not every movie deserves a comeback. The Crow is one such film that should stay buried in the past. Despite the existence of multiple Crow movies, the 1994 original stands out as the most skillfully crafted one and remains more impactful than the four subsequent films in the franchise.

In August 23, 2024, the remake of The Crow was launched, but it received unfavorable criticisms and underperformed at the box office, earning just $22.7 million compared to its production budget of $50 million. One key factor behind its lackluster performance is that we’re no longer in the 1990s, a time when the original film was popular.

Here’s Why The Crow Remake Failed

Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?

The 2024 remake of “The Crow” flopped because the character Eric Draven embodied a ’90s vibe and style that doesn’t resonate with today’s audience. As a heavy metal musician, Eric sported a look befitting the era. On the other hand, Eddie Munson (portrayed by Joseph Quinn) was an entertaining character due to the comical lines in “Stranger Things” season 4, which was set in the ’80s. Given that both characters appear dated, it seemed unnecessary to bring back Eric, portrayed this time by Bill Skarsgard, in 2024.

In more contemporary terms, “The Crow’s” narrative seems more suited for the 1990s rather than the future, like 2024. The plot revolves around Eric Draven (Brandon Lee), who is resurrected by a crow after his and his fiancée Shelly Webster’s (Sofia Shinas) deaths, in order to exact revenge on the gang responsible for their murder. Despite its dark theme, it carries an element of cheesiness that might not translate well if reimagined today. Although the 1990s produced many excellent horror films, not all deserve a remake. The timeless tragic romance between Eric and Shelley is compelling, but it may not be enough to sustain a modern adaptation.

In my opinion, the recent take on “The Crow” has been met with a wave of negative feedback. The Guardian labeled it as an “incomprehensibly dreadful goth reboot,” while Forbes pointed out that it lacks soul. It seems that Eric, the character, may not resonate with audiences in today’s era. On the contrary, Jenna Ortega’s portrayal of Wednesday Addams is a refreshing modern Goth figure. Unfortunately, Eric appears to be trapped in yesteryears. Moreover, given the criticism that the remake closely adhered to the original, it seems that its creation may have been unnecessary.

Participants from the remake and the original version of “The Crow” have expressed diverse views concerning the new film. Notably, Bill Skarsgard discussed the finale of “The Crow” remake in an interview with Esquire, and it appears he wasn’t on board with the creative decisions taken. He stated:

“I personally preferred something more definitive.”

Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?
Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?
Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?
Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?
Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?

The Crow also had a tragedy on set.
Brandon Lee, who played the main character Eric Draven who becomes The Crow, passed away after using a prop gun while filming the horror movie. According to

NPR
, Michael Massee, who played Funboy, fired the prop gun at Lee, and he unfortunately and tragically died.Alex Proyas, who directed the original

The Crow
movie, didn’t think that the remake needed to be made given Lee’s terrible death. According to

Indiewire
, Proyas shared on Facebook:

‘The Crow’ stands for more than just a film. Tragically, Brandon Lee passed away during its production. The movie ultimately served as a poignant tribute to his unrealized talent and untimely demise. It’s a symbol of his legacy – one that continues to resonate.

Inside The Success Of The 1990s Horror Movie The Crow

Why Didn't The Crow Remake Succeed?

The film “The Crow” gained considerable popularity, earning the status of a cult favorite, significantly influencing mainstream culture. Furthermore, it generated approximately $50,710,791 globally at the box office, as reported by Box Office Mojo, a figure that is generally considered commendable.

Based on Loudersound.com reports, numerous metal bands hold the movie in high regard, with singer Ville Valo referring to Eric as his “idol.” If it were released today, it may not elicit the same reaction, but it remains a favorite for many. Characters like Eric and The Crow from ’90s horror films are ones that people fondly recall from that era.

Back when I was still alive, I had a chat with Entertainment Weekly about playing Eric Draven in The Crow. We delved into the heartwarming romance between Eric and Shelley, and how captivating it was to immerse myself in that role’s preparation. To put it simply, I shared my thoughts on what it felt like to embody such a complex character.

“The situation is quite extraordinary. The character experiences a startling resurrection, leaving him initially disoriented as to his location and circumstances… How does this connect to the portrayal of physicality? To ensure an unhealthy appearance, I deliberately shed some pounds for the part.

In a different interpretation, it can be said that: Lee poured his entire heart into the role, and he will forever be recognized as one of the most gifted actors whose time was cut short prematurely. Although the remake of The Crow didn’t achieve greatness, Lee’s lasting impact remains in the 1994 original.

Read More

2024-09-27 02:05