Why the Scope of Hogwarts Legacy’s Sequel is Likely to Be the Same

by

Why the Scope of Hogwarts Legacy's Sequel is Likely to Be the Same

As a seasoned gamer with countless hours spent immersed in various RPGs and fantasy worlds, I must confess that Hogwarts Legacy left me with mixed feelings. On one hand, it offers an enchanting and engaging open-world experience set within the beloved Harry Potter universe, which is hard to resist for any fan. However, its narrative, despite being atmospheric and charming in parts, fails to reach the heights of its potential. The “chosen one” formula feels tired and the overall conflict lacks the necessary stakes to truly captivate me.

Despite having some flaws, Hogwarts Legacy lays a strong foundation for an enthralling and immersive fantasy RPG series. If future installments of Hogwarts Legacy can substantially develop upon their predecessor, enriching both its gameplay mechanics and storyline depth, then it could become something truly remarkable. However, it’s likely that at least one significant limitation will persist.

One of the many criticisms of Hogwarts Legacy is its overall narrative. Atmospheric, charming, and memorable as the game may be in some places, its main story is sadly forgettable and fails to leave a long-lasting impression. The tale follows a rather typical “chosen one” formula, but instead of saving the world from a gross, malignant evil, the protagonist is simply caught in the middle of a Goblin uprising, which threatens a far lower-stakes fate. Questionable implications about the civil rights of magical beings aside, the small scope of both the hero’s special powers and the main conflict can be attributed to the game’s place in the overall Harry Potter timeline, being dictated by what comes after it.

Why Hogwarts Legacy 2 May Not Be Able to Properly Up the Ante

Hogwarts Legacy Is Hogtied to the Harry Potter Mythos

The game titled “Hogwarts Legacy” shares the same storyline as “Harry Potter,” which is evident through numerous significant character, historical, and world-building links between them. This connection means that “Hogwarts Legacy” has certain limitations in terms of its narrative possibilities.

For example, in the game’s finale, Ranrok attempts to demolish Hogwarts. However, given that anyone who has even a slight understanding of Harry Potter is aware that such an action wouldn’t occur because it would conflict with subsequent stories. Essentially, since Hogwarts Legacy occurs before the events depicted in both the Harry Potter series and Fantastic Beasts films, it must avoid drastic consequences to ensure consistency within its established mythology and prevent the creation of plot inconsistencies within the broader franchise.

Hogwarts Legacy Can’t Do Much If It Stays in the Past

While it’s theoretically possible that Hogwarts Legacy 2 could take place in the future, there’s a strong likelihood that it won’t. This prediction is based on several factors, but two key considerations are brand identity and the direction of the Harry Potter series. The original game had a significant challenge – to distinguish itself from the widely known Harry Potter books and films while maintaining familiarity. It managed this, in part, by setting the story in the 1800s, offering fans a new perspective on a world they’ve seen countless times before.

In terms of the continuity of the Harry Potter universe, it’s crucial that the upcoming Hogwarts Legacy game doesn’t overlap with future books, movies, or shows in the series. If Hogwarts Legacy 2 were to be set during or near the events of the books or Fantastic Beasts films, it would limit the creative freedom for future storylines. By advancing the timeline and setting the game after the conclusion of Harry Potter, the developers could create a thrilling, high-stakes tale. However, this approach might restrict the creators’ ability to modify the storyline if they find that they dislike its direction in future installments, leaving them with limited options.

If we imagine that Hogwarts Legacy 2 is a follow-up story, it needs to be mindful not to contradict established lore. This applies equally if the sequel explores earlier time periods. Consequently, this restricts the potential scope of the game’s storyline, potentially limiting the long-term impact or substantial plot progressions that Avalanche Software could create.

Read More

2024-09-28 16:03