Why Whitebeard Might Be Stronger Than Roger: The Hidden Facts Revealed

by

Summary

  • Whitebeard may have been stronger due to the destructive potential of his powerful Devil Fruit.
  • Roger and Whitebeard were equals, but Whitebeard’s Devil Fruit may have given him an edge over his rival.
  • Rocks D. Xebec remains the strongest pirate ever, despite Roger and Whitebeard’s prominence.

In the annals of One Piece, when discussing the most formidable pirates throughout history, Gol D. Roger and Edward ‘Whitebeard’ Newgate are undoubtedly the ones who immediately spring to mind. The former was uniquely titled the Pirate King due to his extraordinary power, while the latter was feared for his incredible might, even being said to possess the ability to annihilate the world.

In their past confrontations within the world of One Piece, these two characters were known for their intense rivalry and were often compared in terms of power. This parity was evident during the epic battle they had during Oden’s flashback in the Wano arc, which lasted an exhausting three days without either gaining a decisive advantage. Yet, many passionate fans argue that Whitebeard was actually the stronger of the two. Let’s delve into the reasons behind this belief.

Why Whitebeard May Have Been Stronger Than Roger

The Truth About Their Rivalry

Roger’s First Appearance One Piece, Chapter 1, “Romance Dawn – The Dawn of Adventure”
Whitebeard’s First Appearance One Piece, Chapter 234, “Please Remember”

In the world of swashbuckling legends, there are few pirates as formidable and impactful as Roger and Whitebeard. Now, I’m not just saying this – these two towered above their peers in strength, influence, and sheer charisma. While Roger was the sole bearer of the title, Pirate King, Whitebeard chose a different path. The title wasn’t his goal; he sought something greater.

Their rivalry, though, is the stuff of sea shanties. They were two titans clashing, equals in every sense who time and again fought to a draw. Their epic battles were as legendary as they were, and their tale continues to echo through the seven seas.

The story clearly portrays these two figures as equals, implying that neither surpassed the other. Nevertheless, some viewers argue that this might not be the complete picture, as there’s a hint suggesting Whitebeard may have been restraining himself against his adversary. Despite numerous confrontations where no clear winner emerged, only one of these encounters has been depicted in the series – their fight during Oden’s flashback in the Wano storyline.

How many years has it been, Newgate?

For three days without pause, both parties engaged in relentless combat, leaving no decisive victor proclaimed. The duel between these two individuals displayed their exceptional command over all Haki techniques, as they exclusively employed this ability throughout the battle. It is evident that their skill and overall power with Haki were equally matched. Yet, some argue that Whitebeard might have been stronger than his opponent due to the fact he refrained from utilizing his Devil Fruit power during his fight against Roger.

Absolutely, it’s important to note that this interpretation is quite speculative as Oda hasn’t depicted any other fights between them. However, many fans imagine this fight serves as a model for their other encounters because Whitebeard and Ace didn’t clash frequently. While their Haki skills were balanced, Whitebeard, being the user of the strongest Devil Fruit in the series, might have had an advantage over his rival.

It is widely thought that, had they not been allies and clashed in full force, Whitebeard would likely have emerged victorious due to the fact that while his Haki was equal to Roger’s, his Devil Fruit ability grants him destructive powers unparalleled by any other character in the series. During the Marineford War, Sengoku himself acknowledged Whitebeard’s immense strength, stating that he possessed the power to annihilate the entire world if he so desired. This statement strongly suggests that his power could have significantly influenced the outcome against Roger.

Despite being unwell and Haki not being as fully developed a concept then as it is now, Whitebeard single-handedly tackled a large portion of the Navy during the Marineford War. This demonstrates that he was essentially an invincible force, whose true might remains undetermined due to his crew constantly being present, thus restricting him from unleashing the full devastation potential of the Gura Gura no Mi Devil Fruit. Some even speculate that if one possesses this Devil Fruit alone, Haki may not be needed at all.

People on the other side argue that Roger was slightly more powerful than Oden, primarily due to their initial encounter where it appeared Roger had fewer issues handling him. However, several aspects contribute to this. Firstly, Roger’s Divine Departure caught Oden off guard, enabling him to rise again after being knocked down. Conversely, while Whitebeard’s fight with Oden lasted longer, a single powerful punch sent Oden flying and knocked him unconscious when he became serious.

The True Strongest Pirate Of All Time Is Still A Mystery

The Legend Who Roger Needed Help From Garp To Defeat

  • Although Roger and Whitebeard are remembered as the strongest of today, Rocks was likely more powerful than them both.

Today’s global populace often recalls Roger and Whitebeard as the mightiest pirates from the past, a perception that generally holds up. Yet, it’s important to consider that this belief stems largely from the suppression of memories about Rocks D. Xebec, a figure who was suggested to be even more powerful than these two pirates. His influence was so great that he came close to surpassing Joyboy himself in power.

Steeped in awe and wonder, I can’t help but marvel at the enigmatic figure of Rocks. Not just any captain, he led the most formidable crew the world has ever seen, with Whitebeard among his ranks. The tales speak of his power as being so immense that even legendary figures like Roger and Garp joined forces to subdue him – a testament to his might that few can match. While the great debate between the strength of Roger and Whitebeard continues, there’s one truth that rings clear: the man who claimed the title of the strongest of their age was none other than Rocks D. Xebec.

One Piece can be streamed on Crunchyroll.

Read More

2025-05-18 16:09