You have used all your credits for this month. Please add more credits to continue.

by

Spoiler Warning: Red Dead Redemption 2 story details ahead

During a second play of Red Dead Redemption 2, many fans find Dutch Van Der Linde increasingly tiresome due to his overly repetitive dialogues and manipulative behavior. As the story progresses in Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch transitions from being a reliable ally and friend into an antagonist with a dominating demeanor, causing players to grow weary of him with each subsequent playthrough, finding his words grating on their ears.

In “Red Dead Redemption 2”, players journey through an authentic Wild West setting as they experience a deep, immersive storyline that reflects the turbulent times when traditional living was being replaced by law and order. The player takes on the role of Arthur Morgan, a member of the Van Der Linde Gang, a group of outlaws struggling to adapt to the changing world. Dutch, their leader, holds onto the old ways, planning one last series of heists to secure enough funds for a fresh start. However, these plans repeatedly fall through, leading to tension within the gang.

Conflicts arise between Dutch and Arthur, leading to an increasingly autocratic leadership style, despite everyone continuing to obey him due to Dutch’s persuasive and captivating personality in Red Dead Redemption 2. While this trait is apparent during the initial gameplay, a Reddit user named UnfairStrategy780 pointed out that after multiple playthroughs, they found Dutch increasingly irritating. In fact, the player expressed that they disliked listening to Dutch’s voice and opted to omit his scenes in subsequent plays.

Players Find Dutch’s Repetitive Speeches ‘Insufferable’ in New RDR2 Playthroughs

As a devoted Red Dead Redemption 2 gamer, I’ve got to say, UnfairStrategy780’s post ignited a lively discussion among us fans. Many of us are finding Dutch’s catchphrases, like “I have a plan,” “we just need money,” and “one more score,” quite grating after hearing them so often. While some of us understand the emotional depth behind Dutch in RDR2, his character evolution makes it hard to ignore that he’s not acting with rationality as the story unfolds.

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch’s transformation into a more malevolent figure can be attributed to several factors: the loss of his comrades, escalating law enforcement pressure, and doubts from the gang about his leadership as things began to fall apart. Some players in online forums argue that Dutch was inherently selfish and didn’t genuinely care about the gang’s welfare—if he did, they claim he would have adjusted his approach to safeguard the group. The intricate development of Dutch’s character and the ongoing discussions among players about it serve as evidence of the profound impact Red Dead Redemption 2 has had on the video game industry.

Read More

2025-05-27 15:44