Isekai Manhwa That Might Be Difficult To Adapt Into An Anime

As a seasoned anime enthusiast with over two decades of viewing under my belt, I must say that each of these manhwas presents a unique challenge when it comes to animation adaptation.

As a passionate gamer immersed in the vibrant world of Isekai Manhwa, there are certain features that set these stories apart: they’re brimming with flamboyance, their combat scenes are meticulously detailed, often featuring intense close-ups and intricate eye animations, all while bursting with special effects. Given the unique blend of action, fantasy, and character development, bringing one of these tales to life as an Isekai anime could potentially lead to a true masterpiece – think ‘Solo Leveling’ or ‘A Returner’s Magic Should Be Special’. However, it also carries the risk of becoming an epic failure.

The risk is way too high, and the rewards are not as great as they seem. So, with that in mind here’s a list of Isekai Manhwa that might be difficult to adapt into an anime. From a classic reincarnation tale, to a story about a skeleton trapped in an infinite loop.

5 The Beginning After The End

Its Battle Scenes Could Be Impossible To Adapt With 100% Fidelity

Genres: Action, Drama, Fantasy, Dark Fantasy, Sword And Sorcery, Isekai
Author: Turtle ME
Status: Hiatus (Until September 2024)

In simpler terms, “The Beginning After The End,” or TBATE, follows the tale of Arthur Leywyn, who was a monarch from another world in his previous life, living in solitude and bearing the weight of being the strongest individual. For unclear reasons, the figure known as King Gray is reborn, taking residence in the body of the eldest son of a retired adventurer duo.

As a passionate gamer immersed in TBATE’s captivating narrative, I can’t help but marvel at its intricate world-building and character designs. However, when it comes to an animated adaptation, there’s a catch: the dynamic battle scenes with their expressive artistry would suffer if not rendered flawlessly. After all, war, survival, and the MC’s evolution through multiple phases are central themes in this epic tale. The intricate designs of creatures, particularly Sylvie, pose a challenge for small-screen adaptation. Here’s hoping a studio renowned for animating Isekai series rises to the occasion and delivers a true masterpiece.

4 I Reincarnated As An Evolving Space Monster

Its Gruesome Scenes Would Be Toned Down For Sure Plus The Legal Issues

Genre: Sci-Fi, Action, Gore, Terror
Authors: FearTurtle (Gongpouigeobug-i)
Status: Ongoing

In this tale, the main character finds himself shifted to a virtual world, transforming into a cosmic beast reminiscent of the Alien xenomorph. Delighted by the prospect, he embarks on a destructive spree while undergoing metamorphosis into an ultimate space monster. This manhwa is truly captivating, boasting exceptional character designs, chilling horror elements, and a plethora of graphic scenes.

In my gaming world, I grapple with this intriguing dilemma: How might they handle an adaptation of this cherished series? Should they soften the gory elements to conform to regulations, or remain loyal to the source material? Most of us die-hard fans know that body horror and gore often go hand in hand, so any hint of censorship in a potential animated version could fall flat.

3 The Extra’s Academy Survival Guide

This One Would Break The Special Effect Budget

Genre: Action, Isekai, Sword & Sorcery, School Life, Shounen, Drama
Authors: Corita (Story), Girin Geurin (Art)
Status: Ongoing

As a gaming enthusiast with an uncanny knack for immersion, I find myself reborn as the unsavory villain, Ed Rothtaylor, in a game world teeming with swords and sorcery. Armed with my deep-seated understanding of the game’s storylines and events, I’ve chosen to tread lightly, keeping a low profile to avoid altering history and ward off unwanted bad endings. However, I’m soon to discover that even the smallest shifts can unleash unexpected consequences.

Initially, his mischievous actions subtly reshape the storyline, elevating him from a supporting character to the main focus, plunging him into a whirlwind of turmoil. Despite being aware of all the potential negative consequences and alternate endings in the game he was brought into, he finds himself unable to escape the spotlight, knowing full well that his actions will cause unforeseeable changes and complications. Crafting this tale with its intricate flashbacks and complexities would be challenging. Moreover, reproducing the numerous summoned creatures, magical battles, and special effects could prove problematic due to budget constraints. Simplifying certain aspects might be necessary, but doing so may require significant adjustments and potentially compromise key elements of the original work. Nonetheless, with careful planning and investment, this could become an exceptional Isekai anime series.

2 The Magic Academy’s Genius Blinker

A Great School-Life Isekai, But Animation Of The MC Could Be An Issue

Genre: Action, Isekai, Fantasy, Sword & Sorcery, School Life, Shounen
Authors: Eunmilhi (Story) Seoyu (Art)
Status: Ongoing

A video game enthusiast finds himself thrust into the immersive universe of a widely acclaimed RPG with rich fantasy elements. He unexpectedly assumes the role of Baek Yu-Seol, a character often dismissed for his unconventional gaming style. This character is particularly skilled in the use of the Blink spell, which is notoriously difficult to master and seemingly inferior compared to other magical abilities. However, due to his unique awareness of future events, he will go to great lengths to prevent the catastrophic ending, as this is his primary mission and the reason behind his arrival in the game world.

Although the narrative boasts charm, excitement, and readability, bringing it to life through animation might prove challenging, even for seasoned studios. This is especially true when considering the main character’s ability to leap around at lightning speed and attack with swift, powerful spellblade slashes. Remarkably, this story shares a similarity with The Extra’s Academy Survival Guide: its spectacle-filled scenes might strain budget constraints significantly, necessitating a substantial reduction in their intensity before production.

1 The Skeleton Soldier Failed To Defend The Dungeon

Animating A Skeleton Is Not As Easy As It Seems

Genres: Dark Fantasy, Drama, Isekai, Action, Adventure
Authors: Sosori (Story), Ant Studio (Art)
Status: Ongoing

As a fan versed in the realm of Isekai and fantasy genres, it’s quite usual to come across skeletons, especially during adventures into dungeons where these bone-chilling creatures seem to lurk around every turn. Yet, even when we witness their animated depictions, they often appear awkward and strikingly low-budget. The reason behind this? They typically serve as mere fodder for the heroes, or as they casually refer to them: XP bags.

From a creative standpoint, animating a comprehensive skeleton character can prove quite challenging – trust me on this! To give you an idea, visualizing a fully-animated skeletal figure for extended periods, let alone presenting it in various planes (especially outside of brief fight sequences or close-ups), is no easy feat. Adding to the difficulty, showing such characters while armored, wearing capes, and displaying expert-level combat skills can be quite taxing on both the animators and the viewers.

2024-09-03 08:04