Ben Stiller’s Bold Move: How Ignoring Fan Theories Could Save TV Shows

by

Summary

  • Ben Stiller avoids fan theories to protect Severance’s creative vision and avoid pandering to audience demands.
  • Fan theories have negatively impacted shows like Game of Thrones, Lost, and Westworld by altering original plans.
  • Creators should trust their instincts over fan feedback to maintain the authenticity and integrity of their storytelling process.

As a devoted cinephile, I’ve come to realize that Ben Stiller’s straightforward yet profound rule for the critically acclaimed “Severance” could shed light on why many popular TV shows often fall short of their audience’s expectations. In an enlightening discussion, the executive producer and main director (of most episodes) of this Apple TV+ series revealed some fascinating insights into his creative process – a practice I believe every major showrunner should emulate.

The eagerly awaited second season finale of Severance airs on March 21, 2025, sparking plenty of speculation among fans about what might transpire. Ben Stiller, who is helming this episode titled “Cold Harbor,” has expressed his views on fan theories and their significance. These perspectives are highly relevant for the evolution of television and streaming platforms.

Ben Stiller Says No To Severance Fan Theories

Will It Protect The Show’s Creative Vision?

Ben Stiller explicitly stated that he’s steering clear of all theories surrounding Severance, during a panel at SXSW with Apple’s Services EVP Eddy Cue. In their discussion, they touched upon the risks of accommodating audience expectations and its impact on creativity. Although the director values the exceptional response to Severance, he expresses concern that fan anticipations could sway decisions and invite criticism if the show doesn’t align with these expectations.

That place is risky due to an overabundance of thoughts. I occasionally tune into certain podcasts, but I keep on listening only until they express any criticism of a specific episode. Once they do, I cease tuning in to those podcasts permanently.

Stiller’s remarks point out a recurring challenge found in many popular TV series, such as “Game of Thrones”, where fan anticipation often runs high, leading viewers to guess about future episodes or seasons. Although speculation and creative fan works are significant aspects of television, it’s crucial for creators to safeguard their authentic storytelling from being overly influenced by these theories. Given the gap of almost three years between the two seasons of “Severance”, it was natural for fans to come up with assumptions regarding Lumon Industries and its staff.

How Fan Theories Can Ruin A Great TV Show

Past Victims Include Lost, Westworld & Game of Thrones

During the initial broadcast of Game of Thrones, fan theories were an integral part of the show. However, with the final season leaving many viewers dissatisfied, some speculate that the writers altered certain plot twists because fans had guessed them earlier. This alteration appears to have weakened the overall narrative solely to maintain an air of unpredictability. Interestingly, George R.R. Martin has stated that if fans can decipher a writer’s plan, it is a testament to good writing.

Examples like “Lost” and “Westworld” demonstrate how fan theories can sometimes undermine creative work. Initially, shows such as “Lost” faced difficulties due to the writers generating numerous enigmas and frequently altering course, resulting in an unsatisfying conclusion. On the other hand, “Westworld” became excessively intricate because its showrunners persistently aimed to outwit fan theories. Some creators of these series have suggested or verified that they altered their plots due to fans predicting crucial twists prematurely.

Severance Season 2 Finale Fan Theories

Discussion boards such as the dedicated subreddit for “Severance” have been inundated with speculations about the potential outcomes of the second season’s finale. The seventh episode made it clear that Gemma is still alive and under observation within the same Lumon facility where Mark and the MDR team carry out their tasks. This revelation has sparked a flurry of theories concerning Lumon’s true objectives or creations, and the reasons behind their clandestine operations.

Earlier this season, certain predictions have proven accurate, like identifying Helly R. as Helena Eagan and foreseeing that a character could be divided more than once. Interestingly, some viewers speculate that Ricken might be an Outie or an Innie, due to his goat-centric home decor and peculiar companions from the initial season. However, a theory that seems more plausible is that the enigmatic Cold Harbor project revolves around love being severed, considering love’s resilience amidst the process of severance.

Severance Is More Than Just Easter Eggs & Shocking Twists

Fan Theories Should Not Influence Series & Films

Ben Stiller’s approach to bypassing theories about “Severance” could appear as a brilliant move in today’s context, but it is essentially common sense. When a storyteller or showrunner starts contemplating multiple endings or fan perspectives prior to concluding the narrative, it disturbs the natural flow of the storyline. Shows like “Severance,” which revolve around mystery and sci-fi elements, benefit from unexpected twists and hidden gems, but fans sometimes delve too deep into minor details.

As a dedicated cinephile, I’ve come to realize that when a storyteller starts leaning too heavily on fan theories instead of their original vision, it can disrupt the narrative’s natural progression. It’s a common pitfall for creators to alter a show based on what fans have “solved,” but the truth is, most viewers simply crave a compelling tale. A twist holds significance only if it continues to resonate upon revisiting the story.

With Severance season 2, there’s been a flurry of theories predicting major plot twists. However, it seems that the creators are more preoccupied with fleshing out their existing concepts rather than unveiling earth-shattering revelations.

Essentially, it’s crucial to understand that creative works such as “Severance” or any other TV show, movie, or media, shouldn’t be altered based on external opinions. While practices like test screenings and focus groups are widespread in the entertainment industry, they should be minimized. Just like Ben Stiller trusts his unique vision for “Severance,” all creators should have faith in their instincts rather than allowing art to succumb to corporate pressures.

Read More

2025-03-20 23:05