Crypto Scores Big Win As US SEC Suffers Loss In ‘Dealer’ Lawsuit

by

As a seasoned crypto investor with over a decade of experience navigating the ever-evolving digital asset landscape, I can’t help but feel a sense of vindication following Judge O’Connor’s ruling against the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The SEC has long been perceived as an overreaching regulatory body, often acting as a hindrance to innovation rather than a guiding force.

In a recent court decision, Judge Reed O’Connor from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas has ruled against the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), stating that their application of the term “securities dealer” lacks legal support under current U.S. legislation.

US SEC Overreach Stemmed Again

The ruling from Judge O’Connor hinges on a lawsuit filed by industry groups, Blockchain Association and Crypto Freedom for Alliance of Texas. The duo challenged the broad use of the term “dealer,” which now forms a mainstay in fighting securities fraud.

The Judge found himself siding with the group of claimants who had objections to the classification of cryptocurrency entities within the securities broker definition. According to their perspective, overly broad use of the term could potentially harm overall market expansion. They contended that this is particularly relevant in the realm of Decentralized Finance (DeFi).

Turning his back against the markets regulator, Judge O’Connor said,

According to Judge O’Connor’s decision, it was found that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) overstepped its legal boundaries by defining a dealer so expansively without considering the context, background, or organization of the Securities Exchange Act.

A significant number of the market regulator’s policies continue to spark debate. The US SEC has incorporated this provision for securities dealers into Rule 3a5-4. This rule, in simpler terms, classifies a dealer as an individual who consistently buys and sells securities, thereby ensuring market liquidity for other participants.

Normally, a dealer is someone who frequently shows interest in buying or selling assets close to the best prices available on both sides of the market. Moreover, they are individuals who make money by taking advantage of the difference between the buying and selling prices, known as Bid-Ask spreads. This wide interpretation makes the crypto market more vulnerable to increased regulation.

Changes Beginning With Gary Gensler’s Resignation

During about the same period, the market regulator was engaged in a legal dispute, coinciding with Gary Gensler’s announcement of his planned departure from the role of U.S. SEC Chair on the specified timeline.

The “dealer,” often referred to as a regulatory body, is known for enforcing rules first. This recent court decision, akin to a lawsuit, can be seen as a lack of confidence. As January 20th approaches, cryptocurrency advocates are growing apprehensive about who will assume the role next, causing uncertainty in the community.

Exciting News: It appears that Paul Atkins, a former SEC commissioner, is currently frontrunning for the position of SEC Chair, as I’ve learned from someone directly involved in the matter. Keep in mind though, as with any developments in Trump’s sphere, things can always shift. Fox Business has reported on this before… (In the context of a crypto investor discussing potential changes in government regulation.)

— Charles Gasparino (@CGasparino) November 21, 2024

Several names are flying under the public’s notice as potential fits for the position. Although Former CFTC Chairman Chris Giancarlo has denied being a contender, sources suggest Paul Atkins as a prominent name to keep an eye on. The cryptocurrency community is advocating for shifts within the US SEC. Experts in the field predict that the President’s selection could significantly impact these desired changes.

Read More

2024-11-22 00:36