Elon Musk Faces US SEC Lawsuit for Securities Fraud in Twitter Deal

by

The United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has brought charges against Elon Musk, claiming he committed securities fraud related to his 2022 purchase of Twitter, which is now known as X. The lawsuit was submitted in a federal court in Washington D.C., stating that Musk broke disclosure regulations while building a significant ownership in the social media platform.

Elon Musk Faces US SEC Lawsuit for Securities Fraud

The SEC’s lawsuit alleges that Elon Musk exceeded the 5% ownership threshold for Twitter stocks in March 2022. Under federal rules, any shareholder who surpasses this limit is required to disclose their shares held within a ten-day timeframe.

As a crypto investor, I found myself in a situation where I didn’t fully disclose some crucial information for a period of 11 days. During this time, I was actively acquiring shares at prices lower than what they might have been had the truth been known publicly.

Based on SEC reports, Musk’s late disclosure allowed him to buy shares from unaware investors, potentially saving him over $150 million. On April 4th, 2022, Musk revealed his investment in Twitter, stating he owned over 9% of the company’s stocks. Coincidentally, within the same week, Twitter announced its intention to join an exchange, causing its stock price to surge by more than 27%.

Legal Team Denies Allegations

In simpler terms, Alex Spiro, who’s Elon Musk’s attorney, stated that the SEC’s accusations against Musk are baseless and that the SEC is persistently targeting him. Spiro explained that the case stems from an administrative issue and emphasized that even if it’s proven Musk failed to submit a form, the repercussions would be minimal.

Over the last few years, there has been a strained dynamic between Elon Musk and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), marked by numerous probes and court disputes.

As a researcher, I’ve come across recent developments concerning Elon Musk and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Previously, he expressed concerns that the agency had been targeting him. Last month, in a conversation with X, Musk disclosed that the SEC had attempted to persuade him to settle the matter by paying a fine. However, when he declined their offer, they chose to press charges instead. Additionally, there has been criticism against the SEC regarding their enforcement of regulations, with a recent lawsuit against Ripple ongoing. Both parties have submitted a stipulation and agreed to file a deferred appendix while the case progresses.

US SEC Seeks Financial Penalties

In the legal dispute, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) seeks the court’s mandate to force Elon Musk to relinquish any alleged earnings resulting from nondisclosure and additionally pay fines for civil misconduct. Furthermore, the SEC is requesting a trial by jury in this matter to determine whether or not Musk has breached securities laws.

Since Elon Musk finalized the $44 billion purchase of Twitter in October 2022, this ongoing lawsuit represents just another instance in a series of legal disputes he’s faced. The agreement was reached following prolonged negotiations and public disagreements between both parties, during which Musk attempted to back out due to concerns about bots on the platform.

This new legal action by the SEC is connected to Musk’s proposed acquisition of Twitter Inc., following a lawsuit filed earlier in 2022 by the Oklahoma Firefighters Pension and Retirement System. They accused Musk of misleading investors about his intentions to buy the company and failing to disclose his plans in a timely manner.

As reported by the pension fund, Musk’s actions influenced the decisions of other shareholders, causing them financial harm via the legal action he initiated, specifically the case known as Rasella v. Musk. This lawsuit was submitted to a federal court in New York, and the proceedings are still ongoing.

As an analyst, I find myself observing a unique confluence of events: The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is currently embroiled in a lawsuit, and this action unfolds amidst shifts in leadership at the agency itself. Outgoing SEC Chair Gary Gensler, who has faced pressure from various business leaders, including Brad Garlinghouse, CEO of Ripple, has announced his resignation effective on January 20th, following the inauguration of President-elect Donald Trump. The incoming administration has expressed a commitment to reducing regulatory burdens that may potentially impact the SEC in the future.

Read More

2025-01-15 09:10