Spot Bitcoin ETF: Why New DTCC Directive Is Both Bullish and Bearish

As a researcher with experience in the financial industry, I find DTCC’s decision to be a significant development that could have far-reaching implications for investors in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds (ETFs). While it may seem like a minor change in the collateral policy, it could potentially lead to less liquidity and increased risks for spot crypto ETF investors.


As a researcher studying financial regulations, I’ve come across an interesting development: The Depository Trust and Clearing Corporation (DTCC) has announced a new policy. Specifically, it will no longer permit exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that hold Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrencies as underlying assets to use its services.

DTCC plans to change collateral policy

A financial services firm specializing in clearing and settlement for capital markets participants announced that it will not offer collateral or lend money to certain Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) as described earlier.

The corporation has announced that they will update the collateral value of their special securities during their annual credit facility renewal, which is scheduled for April 30th.

DTCC views this as an opportunity to significantly transform how position values are monitored for Bitcoin ETFs such as BlackRock’s IBIT and Fidelity Investment’s FBTC, as well as other crypto Exchange-Traded Products (ETPs). This transformation would lead to a complete elimination of the collateral value for these products.

K.O., an ardent supporter of cryptocurrencies, maintains that this recent development pertains exclusively to transactions between entities within the line of credit system. However, he reassures that the application of crypto ETFs for lending purposes and as collateral in brokerage deals will persist unaltered.

However, he pointed out that it is highly dependent on individual brokers’ risk tolerance.

DTCC’s collateral policy affects ETF investors

This action might lead to some intrigue and apprehension among Bitcoin spot ETF investors, who may question the value of their investments as a result. Such doubts could potentially spark a large-scale sell-off, resulting in a substantial decrease in the assets under management (AUM) for these ETFs and the underlying cryptocurrency.

Based on Autism Capital’s analysis, the DTCC’s declaration might lead to decreased market liquidity, while simultaneously increasing risks for investors in spot crypto Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs).

Starting from next Tuesday, the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC) announced that ETFs holding Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies will not provide any collateral value for loans. This change could result in fewer liquidity options and increased risks for investors. However, it may also serve to minimize potential manipulation and leverage-related activities on Wall Street. Proceed with caution?

— Autism Capital 🧩 (@AutismCapital) April 27, 2024

From an optimistic perspective, making this decision could help reduce the influence of Wall Street firms on the emerging crypto ETF market. The long-term implications for investors and relevant parties remain to be seen.

Read More

2024-04-27 16:54