A player of Red Dead Redemption 2 has come up with a fascinating theory about Dutch, Micah, and the gang’s stolen money. Many fans believe this theory is spot-on and, if true, could dramatically change how we understand the game’s story.
Players of Red Dead Redemption 2 will remember the game starts with the Van der Linde gang on the run after a failed robbery. They managed to steal a lot of money, and the plan was always to return and collect it from Blackwater. But a new idea suggests that whole story about the money in Blackwater might not be true.
Red Dead Redemption 2 Theory Says Dutch Lied About the Money
A player named tomatostem has proposed an interesting theory: the money from the heist wasn’t actually lost in Blackwater. Instead, they suggest Dutch secretly kept it all along. Although this contradicts the game’s narrative and sounds far-fetched at first, tomatostem presented evidence that has swayed many players. Their idea is that the story about the money being stuck in Blackwater was a fabrication. Dutch supposedly had Micah hide it somewhere around Mount Hagen, and used the Blackwater story as a way to keep the gang under his control.
Guess the games from the emojis.
Gamoji
Guess the game from the emojis.
Title
Clues
Results
Title
— Clues
—
The player has offered further evidence to support their theory about the game’s events. They believe Dutch may have been upset with John for several reasons and might have even instructed Micah to eliminate him when they were sent on a scouting mission. This happened while the rest of the gang was struggling to survive and find shelter in the mountains. The player points to Dutch’s specific wording – saying he and Arthur would look for “one of them” – as proof. They also suggest Mount Hagen, located between Blackwater and Colter (the game’s starting area), could have been used to hide the stolen money during their escape. Finally, the player argues that Arthur only contracted tuberculosis because the gang desperately needed money, a situation that wouldn’t have arisen if they’d been able to access the funds in Blackwater.
A popular theory on Reddit, currently with over 1,500 upvotes, suggests a possible explanation for a game mystery. Many players find the theory convincing. While some point out that hiding the money in Blackwater was risky, others believe a remote, harsh mountain location would have been a better choice. However, a counterargument suggests that Blackwater might have been the only option if the amount of gold was too heavy or difficult to move quickly while being chased by authorities.
Put the consoles in the correct order.
Order the selected consoles from lowest to highest.
Your Order
Results
— —
Whether this theory about Red Dead Redemption 2 is true is something only the game’s writers can confirm. Though not universally accepted, many players find it convincing, and it’s likely to impact how they see Dutch van der Linde and the story’s unfolding events.
Read More
- Forza Horizon 6: Find the Ohtani Treasure Chest Location
- LEGO Batman Legacy of the Dark Knight Batcave Minikits & WayneTech Caches
- NTE Drift Guide (& Best Car Mods for Drifting)
- Diablo 4 Best Loot Filter Codes
- PS Plus Monthly Games for June 2026 Wish List
- USD CNY PREDICTION
- USD RUB PREDICTION
- GBP CNY PREDICTION
- CNY RUB PREDICTION
- Cookie Run Kingdom Timeline of Fate Update Guide
2026-05-28 12:04