Top Strategy Critic Asks ‘Fundamental’ Question

by

Is Bitcoin the New Gold or Just Fool’s Gold? 🤔💰

In a world where logic often takes a holiday, the illustrious Jim Chanos, a short-seller of some renown (and a penchant for betting against giants like Enron before it went belly-up in 2001), has decided to grace the X social media network with a question that could make even the most stoic philosopher raise an eyebrow. 🧐

Chanos, in his infinite wisdom, is pondering whether the esteemed company known as Strategy is actually deriving its value from its Bitcoin investments or if it’s merely basking in the warm glow of the market premium to the net asset value (or as the cool kids call it, the mNAV premium). It’s a bit like asking if the chicken came before the egg, or if the egg was just a really confused chicken. 🐔🥚

The Fundamental Bitcoin Treasury Company Question: Does the business model of raising capital to simply buy Bitcoin create the mNAV premium, or does the existence of an mNAV premium create/allow the business model?

— James Chanos (@RealJimChanos) June 19, 2025

Meanwhile, Jeff Walton, a prominent cheerleader for Strategy, argues that Bitcoin is acting as collateral, making it possible for the company to raise capital cheaper than a discount bin at a thrift store. “It’s almost like this idea is so simple, it sounds too good to be true,” Walton mused, probably while sipping a latte and contemplating the mysteries of the universe. He also pointed out that Strategy has more capital than Kynikos Associates had at its peak, which is like saying a whale has more mass than a goldfish. 🐋🐟

Chanos, whose fund specializes in sniffing out overvalued and fraudulent companies like a bloodhound on a scent trail, has placed a bet against Strategy while simultaneously hedging his bets with Bitcoin buys. It’s a bit like trying to catch a fish while also trying to avoid getting wet. 🎣

He believes that Strategy’s current premium is as justified as a cat wearing a top hat, attributing it to the hype generated by retail investors who seem to think they’ve discovered the Holy Grail of investments. The crux of Chanos’s bet is that this premium will eventually evaporate like a mirage in the desert, thanks to the existence of more efficient alternatives like Bitcoin ETFs. 🏜️

Meanwhile, Saylor has issued a warning that Chanos could find himself liquidated if his company’s shares decide to take a rocket ride. Simon Gerovich, the CEO of the Japanese Strategy copycat Metaplanet, is also encouraging the famous short-seller to take a leap of faith against his company. It’s like watching a game of chess where all the pieces are trying to outsmart each other while simultaneously trying to avoid being knocked off the board. ♟️

Chanos, for instance, has also been a longtime bear on Tesla, and let’s just say that this short has backfired on him like a poorly made soufflé. In December 2020, he admitted that this was a “painful” bet, which is a bit like saying that stepping on a Lego is mildly uncomfortable. 🦶🧱

Read More

2025-06-19 23:26