US SEC Takes Major Blow In Chevron Howey Test Case, Implication For Crypto

As a researcher with a background in administrative law and experience following the regulatory landscape in the cryptocurrency industry, I believe the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn the Chevron deference rule marks the end of an era for regulators, particularly the SEC. The Chevron deference rule has given agencies like the SEC significant power to interpret and enforce laws without Congressional oversight, leading to a long-standing regulatory crackdown on crypto firms.


The resolution of the high-profile Chevron case could mark the end of the prolonged SEC enforcement action in securities disputes.

Court Decision Marks the End of Regulators’ Tyranny

As a crypto investor, I was thrilled to learn that on Friday, the Supreme Court made a landmark decision overturning a previous ruling that had granted federal authorities extensive regulatory power for decades. This means that there could be significant changes coming in the way our industry is regulated, which could lead to new opportunities and innovations. Stay tuned for updates!

In the 1984 ruling of Chevron v. National Resources Defense Council, the power was granted to regulatory bodies like the SEC to implement changes in regulations without requiring approval from Congress when a statute’s meaning is unclear. This judgment set the precedent for courts to respect the judgments and expertise of these regulatory agencies concerning the laws they oversee. These regulatory entities are renowned for interpreting and enforcing the legislations assigned to them.

Chevron being overturned may be the biggest news for the crypto industry ever.

From my perspective as an analyst, the SEC’s interpretation of the Howey test regarding the classification of crypto assets as securities or not holds little weight in a court of law.

Courts will now make their…

— The Wolf Of All Streets (@scottmelker) June 28, 2024

As a crypto investor, I’ve come to understand that regulatory bodies have been proactive in addressing time-sensitive issues in our industry, despite the absence of new laws from Congress. The Chief Justice, John Roberts, recently acknowledged the limitations of the Chevron deference rule. In simpler terms, he pointed out that this doctrine allows regulatory agencies to alter their course without seeking approval from Congress first.

I argue from the administration’s perspective that the Supreme Court should uphold the Chevron deference, a fundamental principle in administrative law.

SEC Crackdown on Crypto Firms

As a researcher studying the regulatory landscape of cryptocurrency exchanges, I’ve observed that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has taken a firm stance against certain exchanges, even including some major industry players. This crackdown was bolstered by the Chevron deference rule, which allows the SEC to interpret its own regulations in light of changing market conditions. The SEC has repeatedly relied on the Howey Test as justification for shutting down cryptocurrency activities on these exchanges.

Coinbase, Binance, and Kraken are among the numerous cryptocurrency exchanges that have faced scrutiny from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over allegations of selling unregistered securities. Ripple‘s legal battle with the SEC regarding XRP has been ongoing for three years, making it a significant case in this context. The recent ruling by the Supreme Court on this issue sets an important precedent for all pending crypto-related cases before the regulator.

As an analyst, I’d rephrase it as follows: I’m currently working on a case where the Commission is locked in a legal battle with Coinbase over their denial of a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request. This dispute also involves the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), and Coinbase has asked the court to force both agencies to disclose the requested information.

Significant occurrence: Yesterday’s announcement arrives swiftly following the Supreme Court decision granting defendants in securities fraud cases the privilege of a jury trial in federal courts.

Read More

2024-06-28 19:58