Why Bitcoin Won’t Be King (But Could Still Wear a Crown) 👑💸

by

Ah, Bitcoin-the digital darling of the 21st century, the rebel currency that promised to overthrow the financial establishment. In recent years, it has strutted into the spotlight as a potential asset for reserve managers and national governments alike. But let’s not get carried away, dear reader. Despite its growing popularity (and El Salvador’s President Bukele gleefully riding his Bitcoin wave 🏄‍♂️), this crypto upstart is still far from dethroning the almighty dollar or even gold. Structural flaws? Oh, they’re there, lurking like gremlins in the blockchain.

This opinion piece comes to you courtesy of James Murrell, a seasoned crypto wizard with over six years of experience navigating the choppy waters of fintech startups. James began his blockchain odyssey in 2013, though we suspect he didn’t predict NFTs of pixelated apes back then 🐒.

First things first: Why do countries hoard reserves, and why is the USD king?

Global foreign exchange reserves now sit at a whopping $12 trillion, up from a mere $2 trillion in 2000. The U.S. dollar reigns supreme (~58%), followed by the euro (~20%). And yes, gold is making a comeback, especially among emerging markets that seem to have caught gold fever. But why do countries bother amassing these reserves? Is it greed? Vanity? A love for shiny things? Not quite.

Reserves act as a financial safety net, cushioning economies from sudden capital outflows and currency crashes. Think of them as an insurance policy against economic chaos. Remember Mexico’s Tequila Crisis? Or the UK’s Black Wednesday? How about Russia’s sovereign default in the 1990s? These episodes remind us that when the financial tide goes out, reserves are the lifeboats keeping nations afloat 🚢.

For some countries, like China, reserve accumulation is less about crisis management and more about the natural result of running trade surpluses. Excess savings get parked abroad, often in U.S. Treasuries, because where else would you put your trillions? Under the mattress? 😅

Why Bitcoin won’t be the next global reserve currency (spoiler: it’s not ready for prime time)

Now, let’s address the elephant in the room-or should we say, the digital elephant? Bitcoin enthusiasts may dream of a world where BTC replaces the dollar, but alas, it’s not happening anytime soon. Why? Because Bitcoin lacks the backing of a stable economy, isn’t widely used for trade invoicing, and can’t compete with the liquidity of sovereign bond markets like the U.S. Treasury market. Simply put, Bitcoin is the quirky indie band, while the dollar is the chart-topping pop star 🎤.

To put it in perspective, the U.S. Treasury market boasts a daily trading volume roughly 70 times greater than Bitcoin’s-and a market cap about 25 times larger. Bitcoin’s volatility is also laughably high, ranging between 50% and 100% annually (and spiking to 150%+ during crises). Compare that to the U.S. 10-year Treasury note, which exhibits a calm 5-8% annualized volatility. It’s like comparing a rollercoaster 🎢 to a leisurely stroll in the park.

Bitcoin’s market structure doesn’t help either. Wide bid-ask spreads, shallow order books, and fragmented trading venues make it less appealing to FX reserve managers. Imagine trying to sell billions of dollars’ worth of Bitcoin in a pinch-it would be like trying to empty a swimming pool with a teaspoon. Meanwhile, Japan’s Ministry of Finance managed to spend $60 billion in 2022 and nearly $100 billion in 2024 defending the yen without breaking a sweat. Could they do that with Bitcoin? Not unless they enjoy financial chaos 🌋.

But wait-there’s still hope for our digital friend!

All is not lost for Bitcoin, however. Senior politicians like ECB President Christine Lagarde may scoff at the idea of including it in reserves, but their stubbornness only fuels the fiery divide between traditional policymakers and the crypto community 🔥. What they fail to see is that Bitcoin has unique qualities that make it worth considering.

In a world of rising geopolitical fragmentation, Bitcoin offers a hedge against sovereign counterparty risk. Trade barriers are up, capital controls are back on the table, and sanctions are thrown around like confetti. Amidst this chaos, Bitcoin stands apart because it’s not tied to any single government. It’s the Switzerland of currencies-if Switzerland were run by code and memes 🧳.

Moreover, Bitcoin complements gold, that ancient store of value beloved by central banks. While gold requires physical storage and custody checks, Bitcoin is sleek, divisible, and virtually impossible to counterfeit. It’s like upgrading from a horse-drawn carriage to a Tesla 🚗⚡. Sure, it’s not perfect, but younger generations increasingly view it as a safe haven. Plus, with regulatory frameworks like Europe’s MiCA and the U.S.’s FIT21 taking shape, Bitcoin is slowly shedding its Wild West reputation.

A bold new future (or at least a slightly less boring one)

Skepticism toward disruptive innovation is nothing new. People once doubted cloud computing, electronic trading, and even the shift from gold to U.S. Treasuries after World War II. Yet here we are, with Treasuries forming the bedrock of global reserves. Bitcoin may not replace these stalwarts, but it can carve out a niche as a complementary asset, adding diversity and a dash of modernity to reserve portfolios 🎨.

As institutional giants like BlackRock and Fidelity dip their toes into the crypto waters, the case for Bitcoin grows stronger. Governments may resist, but resistance is futile-or so says every sci-fi movie ever made 🛸. So, while Bitcoin won’t wear the crown just yet, it might at least earn a place in the royal court. And who knows? Maybe one day, it’ll rule them all. Or at least share the throne with the dollar. Stranger things have happened, right? 😉

Read More

2025-09-09 08:30