As a seasoned researcher with a keen interest in blockchain technology and financial regulations, I find myself closely following the ongoing legal saga between Kraken and the SEC. With years of experience under my belt, I have witnessed numerous twists and turns in similar cases, making this battle particularly intriguing.
In the continuous court dispute between Kraken and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), a significant ruling has been made concerning the submission related to the discovery letter that was presented by the cryptocurrency trading platform.
A judge has denied Kraken’s request to compel the production of documents and information concerning Bitcoin and Ether, the SEC’s public statements and testimony regarding digital assets, and the regulator’s internal trading policies on digital assets.
Court Denies Kraken’s Requests in US SEC Lawsuit
According to the recent court filing in the Northern District of California, Magistrate Judge Robert Illman refused Kraken’s demands for access to crucial documents held by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). This decision marks the resolution of the lingering discovery disagreement between the two parties.
Kraken, a company, asked for an order that would make the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) hand over documents explaining why Bitcoin and Ether were not part of the SEC’s lawsuit, despite these digital currencies being traded in a way similar to 11 other cryptocurrencies on their platform. However, the judge found this main point, or argument, “unconvincing”.
According to the court, the Production Request (RFP) is considered overly wide-ranging and not directly connected to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) accusations regarding the sales of 11 cryptocurrencies. The court argues that fulfilling this request will result in an undue increase in workload for both parties involved.
Judge Also Rejected SEC’s Policy and Public Statements Relevance
Kraken inquired about the SEC’s regulations, guidelines, and use of the Howey test for tokens traded on their platform, specifically mentioning tokens like ADA, ALGO, ATOM, FIL, FLOW, ICP, MANA, MATIC, NEAR, OMG, and SOL. However, the magistrate judge clarified that the SEC’s policies and guidelines aren’t solely applicable to these mentioned tokens alone.
According to the judge’s decision, the case can be resolved without a hearing. The judge has provided the following reasons for denying the defendants’ request for the information they sought.
Furthermore, the judge dismissed Kraken’s request for proof concerning public declarations made by the SEC regarding digital asset regulations.
“The trading community and the crypto sector argue that a previous speech by William Hinman, who used to head an SEC division, provides insight into whether Bitcoin and Ether fall under federal securities regulations. However, Kraken seems unwilling to independently provide reasons for seeking access to information.
US SEC Arguments in Case
Previously, Judge William Orrick ruled that the agreements and presumptions regarding the transaction could potentially be classified as an investment contract. Given this ruling, Judge Orrick previously declined Kraken’s request to discard the SEC lawsuit.
The SEC’s pleadings alleged that during their initial offerings and subsequent transactions on Kraken those assets were sold as investment contracts.
Significantly, Kraken has presented arguments for a “fair notice defense” and the “major questions doctrine” in the SEC lawsuit. Yet, the court asserts that the exchange has addressed broader cryptocurrency regulatory matters, but hasn’t specifically focused on the details of the cryptocurrency transactions at hand.
Simultaneously, by January 15th, the SEC plans to submit its main argument in response to Ripple‘s appeal. Notably, Ripple has also filed a cross-appeal aiming to challenge the SEC’s rules and guidance, arguing they are inconsistent and unclear. This challenge encompasses the fair notice defense, the definition of an investment contract, and the classification of XRP sales as securities by institutional sellers.
Read More
- USD PHP PREDICTION
- POL PREDICTION. POL cryptocurrency
- Brent Oil Forecast
- Hunter x Hunter: Togashi Reveals the Rarest Nen Type In The Series
- OKB PREDICTION. OKB cryptocurrency
- LUNC PREDICTION. LUNC cryptocurrency
- EUR ZAR PREDICTION
- Pokemon Is Collaborating With Dua Lipa
- Final Fantasy 7 Gets Switch Update
- HBOs The Last of Us Used Heavy Make-up To Cover One Characters Real-Life Injury
2024-12-18 19:13