Summary
- Rocks D. Xebec and Gol D. Roger shared a legendary rivalry.
- Speculation suggests they were once friends who became enemies.
- However, a lack of concrete evidence makes the theory uncertain.
In the Elbaf storyline, the God Valley Incident continues to be a significant and enigmatic mystery within the world of One Piece. The cause behind this mysterious event and the specifics of what transpired are largely shrouded in obscurity. The main figures involved and the fact that the Rocks Pirates invaded the island to retrieve their stolen treasure are the only facts known, with many details left unexplored.
From Sengoku’s perspective, Rocks D. Xebec was one of the most formidable pirates in One Piece lore and a formidable rival to the legendary Roger. As one might anticipate, this suggests a past connection between these two titans that transcends mere enmity towards becoming the Pirate King. In this piece, we delve into a widely-discussed fan theory shedding light on their bond.
Gol D. Roger And Rocks D. Xebec Were Friends Before Enemies
An Attempt At Explaining Their Rivalry
| Roger’s First Appearance | One Piece, Chapter 1, “Romance Dawn – The Dawn of Adventure” |
|---|---|
| Rocks’ First Appearance | One Piece, Chapter 957, “Ultimate” |
It’s been widely believed that the most formidable pirates prior to the events portrayed in the story were Roger the Pirate King and Whitebeard. These two giants of piracy were contemporaries, often spoken of as being equally powerful. The Pirate King Roger was the sole individual to ever bear that title, while Whitebeard, though not seeking the One Piece for himself, came the closest among all others in terms of raw power and influence.
People thought for a long time that Roger the Pirate King and Whitebeard were the best pirates before the story started. They both lived at the same time and were believed to be equally strong. Roger was the only one who actually became the Pirate King, while Whitebeard came very close without actively searching for the One Piece himself.
Initially, it seemed that Roger and Whitebeard were the mightiest pirates who ruled the seas, but as the tale unfolded, it became clear that there was a character named Rocks D. Xebec who was considered the strongest among them all. Moreover, his pirate crew was the most powerful in history. This individual was portrayed as Roger’s toughest and most formidable adversary, which is quite significant given that Roger was active at the same time as Whitebeard, Garp, and even St. Figarland Garling.
(Word count: 57)
Many fans assume that the intense and ongoing rivalry between these characters is significant because they have a shared past. While this idea is purely speculative from hereon, it does align with their character ambitions and the fact that their crews were long-standing rivals. One popular fan theory suggests that Roger and Rocks might have been friends at one point, but over time grew apart and became enemies.
In the world of One Piece, there’s a well-known idea known as ‘Saké Brothers’. This term is used to symbolize an unbreakable bond between characters who aren’t biologically related, forged when they share the same cup of Saké. Characters like Luffy, Ace, and Sabo exemplify this bond, suggesting that Roger and Rocks might have started off as friends who later became adversaries.
Regardless of which pirate vessel we sail on, the three of us will forever remain like brothers!
It’s apparent that Roger and Luffy bear several resemblances, and their characters are often compared. If Luffy has the Saké Brothers, one of whom is Roger’s son, it might suggest that Roger too had siblings. Just like Luffy, he might have been separated from his brothers, with each joining distinct influential groups. This pattern could echo the story of Roger, Rocks, and potentially Garp, a theory many fans propose as plausible.
Despite some significant distinctions among these three characters, they ultimately find themselves separated. During the Marineford War, we learn in a flashback that Roger entrusted Ace to Garp, suggesting a strong bond of trust between them. This backstory imbues their confrontation with Rocks with a poignant sense of tragedy. Additionally, when Roger arrived at God Valley, he mentioned it had been a year, indicating a connection between him and Rocks.
How Likely Is This Theory To Be True?
A Theory Built On Speculation
- While a fun theory to think about, there is very little evidence behind it, and it’s based on too much speculation.
Regrettably, while this idea may seem intriguing, it lacks solid evidence due to its tenuous connections and excessive speculation. However, given Oda’s knack for weaving together seemingly disparate elements into a coherent whole, it isn’t entirely implausible.
Until further details about the God Valley Incident emerge, it’s not a theory that fans can fully trust as factual. It seems doubtful that Roger and Rocks were rivals if Rocks was merely another pirate, but for now, there’s no concrete evidence to support this fan theory. For the time being, fans must be patient and wait for Oda to expand on the God Valley Incident, which will likely shed light on the complex relationship between these legendary pirates.
One Piece can be streamed on Crunchyroll.
Read More
2025-05-25 15:14