Fans Think American Horror Stories ‘Lake’ Has The Worst Ending

by

Fans Think American Horror Stories 'Lake' Has The Worst Ending

Key Takeaways

  • Fans criticize the ending of “Lake” in American Horror Stories, finding Jeffrey’s passive response to the zombies odd.
  • Viewers expected a more satisfying conclusion to the episode, questioning Erin and Finn’s lack of action against the evil threat.
  • Despite a compelling setup involving a mysterious lake, the flat ending of “Lake” left fans disappointed and wishing for more.

As a long-time fan of the horror genre and someone who has binge-watched American Horror Stories since its premiere, I must admit that the ending of the episode “Lake” left me feeling quite underwhelmed. I’ve come to expect thrilling conclusions from this series, but the passive response from Jeffrey in the face of zombie hordes was just plain odd.

Ever since its debut in 2021, the chilling anthology series, “American Horror Stories,” has unveiled unforeseen antagonists, delved into familiar horror themes, and served up ample frights. Episodes such as “Leprechaun” can evoke a sense of sadness, while others may leave you feeling disturbed and on edge. Regardless, viewers are always in for a few surprises – be it an intriguing plot twist midway through the episode or an unexpected revelation in the closing scene.

Regardless of the ongoing fascination with chilling characters, spine-tingling tales about creatures lurking under beds, peculiar robots, and sinister hospitals (which are just some highlights from the latest season), there is an episode that has garnered particular attention due to its cringeworthy and implausible conclusion. To put it simply, fans find the ending of one “American Horror Stories” episode hard to swallow.

Why Fans Don’t Like The Ending Of The American Horror Stories Episode “Lake”

Fans Think American Horror Stories 'Lake' Has The Worst Ending

Hey there fellow gamers! In a heartfelt Reddit discussion, I shared my thoughts about the disheartening finale of American Horror Stories season 2, episode 8, titled “Lake.” As we delve into the storyline, Erin (played by Alicia Silverstone), her hubby Jeffrey (Teddy Sears), and their daughter Finn (Olivia Rouyre) unwind at their family’s serene lake house. Here’s where things take a dark turn – it turns out that Jeffrey, unbeknownst to Erin and Finn, belongs to the Prescott clan. The chilling twist reveals that the undead lurking beneath the lake have been biding their time to exact revenge on the Prescotts for killing them and constructing a dam eons ago. As the episode unfolds, Jeffrey is brutally attacked by the zombies, leaving Erin and Finn in a state of utter shock and sorrow.

In the story “Lake”, Jeffrey’s actions at the end, where he lets the zombies push him into the water, appear unusual. Some viewers and readers, such as Redditor @ChelseaCola, have found it odd that Jeffrey doesn’t put up more of a fight in this critical situation, given his character up until then.

As I looked on, in the end, my father wasn’t so much fighting, but more like riding the waves, getting carried away by the crowd and seemingly enjoying a spontaneous ride into the lake, if you will.

Reddit user @Shannonam concurred that the other characters should act more assertively in this frightening scenario. They expressed their thoughts by saying, “it’s hard to believe someone would simply stand by while skeletons from a lake abduct and murder their spouse or father without putting up a fight.” The concept behind “Lake” is just as intriguing as the teaser for season 4 of American Horror Stories, leaving viewers curious about the lake’s enigma and peril. However, it was disappointing to find that the conclusion didn’t live up to expectations.

although the start and mid-section of “Lake,” an episode from American Horror Stories, was captivating, they felt the ending lacked excitement. The initial scenes, set in a picturesque location, intrigued fans who anticipated discovering mysteries hidden beneath the lake. As expected, secrets were indeed revealed, explaining how the Prescotts constructed the town with malicious intentions. However, it seemed odd to some that Erin and Finn didn’t put up more of a fight against the zombies at the end.

The Redditor shared how they felt about getting to the final scene:

Initially, I found the topic engaging – discussing underwater ghost towns is intriguing. However, the ending seemed disappointing and lacked impact.

As a gamer, I’ve got to say, Redditor @stewaycol hit the nail on the head with his observation about the “Lake” ending in American Horror Stories. It just doesn’t add up why Erin and the kids would be clueless about Jeffrey being a Prescott. Even though an unexpected reveal can make for a thrilling plot twist, this one felt completely out of left field. I mean, come on, wouldn’t it be more believable if Erin had been in on the secret all along? Compared to seasons 1 and 2, “Lake” has the most puzzling ending that leaves me scratching my head. It would have made for a far more intriguing story if Erin had dropped the bombshell about Jeffrey’s family background earlier on.

What Is The American Horror Stories Episode “Lake” About?

Fans Think American Horror Stories 'Lake' Has The Worst Ending

The “Lake” episode of “American Horror Stories” primarily revolves around a family coping with the tragic demise of their son, Jake. Following his untimely death in the lake, his sister Finn undergoes therapy to deal with her emotional turmoil. Upon Finn’s return home, Erin makes every effort to assist her daughter in readjusting. However, Erin starts noticing peculiar occurrences within her household, such as the kitchen tap mysteriously activating on its own and the bathwater mysteriously turning green.

Instead of constantly working and neglecting his family, Jeffrey, as unlikable as he seems, spends all his time at work. Erin and Finn notice something amiss in their household. They decide to probe deeper into the mystery surrounding their lake, eventually discovering a startling truth about Jeffrey’s true identity. Similar to the compassionate protagonist in the “Bestie” episode of American Horror Stories, one can empathize with Erin and Finn’s predicament. However, Jeffrey is clearly an unsympathetic character, even before his surprising revelation. In conclusion, “Lake,” an episode from American Horror Stories, offers an entertaining viewing experience, but leaves one yearning for a more satisfying resolution.

Read More

2024-11-04 00:06