Why Every Spy Game Should Force You to Fail (And Why They Don’t)

by

The new James Bond game, 007 First Light, is almost here, and we’re hoping it will be a fresh, groundbreaking addition to the world of spy games. While spy games aren’t really a distinct genre on their own – they usually fall under action or stealth – 007 First Light could potentially change that.

It will be fascinating to see how First Light plays out as a stealth-action game with open-ended gameplay. IO Interactive is known for the Hitman series, which usually focuses on careful planning and elaborate traps executed by the highly skilled Agent 47. James Bond stories, on the other hand, are often more about action and seeing Bond face challenges – a good Bond film typically has a point where things get difficult for him. While capable, Bond isn’t always winning, and that push and pull is something many spy games lack.

The Importance of Failure, and How Spy Games Use Power Fantasies as a Narrative Crutch

As a huge James Bond fan, I’ve noticed something pretty consistent across all the movies – Bond always ends up in trouble! Whether he’s captured, poisoned, or hurt, the villains usually get the upper hand at some point. And thinking about the Daniel Craig films specifically, some of the most memorable moments for me are when he’s literally tied to a chair! I think it happens a lot because it’s a great way to raise the stakes. When our hero faces a challenge bigger than anything they’ve dealt with before, it creates tension, and that’s what makes it so exciting to watch.

Rearrange the covers into the correct US release order.

Easy (5)Medium (7)Hard (10)

Your Order

Results

—

— —

More Games

Looking at this type of event through the style of spy video games highlights a common issue with the medium: games often let players feel incredibly powerful, especially when they become skilled at playing. For example, a good Splinter Cell player can complete a level without being detected. Being caught is seen as a failure, or at least not playing very well. While it can be enjoyable to recover after being spotted, the goal is always to avoid capture. But what if spy games allowed players to fail? And is it worth limiting player control to tell a better story?

How Spy and Stealth Games Can Force the Player to Fail, in a Good Way

When I think about spy games where failing doesn’t just end the game, the Metal Gear Solid series immediately comes to mind. These games often have the player character captured, like when Naked Snake is captured in Metal Gear Solid 3, or Solid Snake is captured and interrogated in the original Metal Gear Solid. These moments are memorable and can offer unique gameplay, but they’re usually pre-planned story events, not things that happen naturally as a result of how you play.

Balance the critic averages
Easy (6)Medium (8)Hard (10)

Critical Mass

Pick games to balance the averages.

Time: 00:00
Diff: —

Scales

Multiplier ×1.00
Left
Avg —
Right
Avg —

Results

0
—
More Games
Choose a game

It’s possible that including scenes where a spy is captured or tortured is a good approach, especially since these ‘failure scenes’ work well in movies like James Bond by creating a low point in the story. However, video games offer something more. Their strength is in being dynamic and unpredictable. Maybe spy games should take a cue from games like The Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim, which have complex capture systems. This would allow players to truly feel like skilled spies, forcing them to use their wits to escape difficult situations – just like a real-life secret agent.

Read More

2026-05-19 12:04